Showing posts with label Michelin Stars. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Michelin Stars. Show all posts

Saturday, 9 November 2013

Restaurant Review: The Waterside Inn Bray

It was the third anniversary of my girlfriend and I getting together and what better way to for two budding foodies to celebrate a special occasion than by going out for a meal? More in hope than in faith we applied (yes applied) for table reservations at the Waterside Inn. The other three Michelin starred restaurant in Bray.

Much to our surprise, our application was successful so on the day of our anniversary we packed into the car and headed off to Bray. When we got there, we encountered the first issue of the night. Valet parking. In front of us was a fleet of Audis, behind a queue of Range Rovers. We however were in a Corsa. A pink Corsa. Needless to say, we felt a wee bit out of place. The parking attendant did however have the good grace to keep a straight face... just!

We got in and were greeted in hushed, deferential tones although it was not immediately clear whether these were directed at us or the institution. In the waiting room we were presented with menus, canapés and a drink.

Fairly quickly I decided that the tasting menu was the order of the day. So far so good. Unfortunately, when I highlighted my egg allergy, things started to go a bit wrong. I thought that, as dishes with eggs were highlighted on the menu, the kitchen would be well versed in mitigating their use. Apparently not. The waiter seemed rather flummoxed and unsettled by my revelation. Ultimately this resulted in me getting most of the dishes but some were missing elements. This I could cope with but where I felt really let down were the dessert courses. My first was substituted with a cheese board which wasn't entirely bad news. The second was substituted with a plate of fruit. This was more suitable to places where Michelins are fitted rather than awarded. Given Roux is a noted pastry chef amongst his other talents, I expected better. I was similarly let down by the petit fours with coffee. Four rather bland fruit jellies were hardly a substitute and left me feeling distinctly fobbed off.

What didn't help was a bit of a language barrier. Having a degree in Biology along with living with food allergies for 27 years means I have come to understand allergies rather well. If I hear how eggs feature in a dish, I usually have a fairly good idea how I will react to them (as well as having a decent chance of explaining why). Unfortunately the waiter and I couldn't find a common language for me to say this so in the end, I gave up.

So beyond that, how was the rest of the food? If I were to sum it up in one sentence it would be: nice but uninspiring. My lobster starter was delicious but spoiled by the heap of green stuff that looked like it had come straight out of a supermarket salad bag and gave the dish the feel of being served in a greasy-spoon "caff" rather than a world renowned restaurant. Next was a very tasty chestnut and champagne veloute with a lovely mouth-feel and mine was served without the foie gras. However it was a bit on the heavy side for something so early in the meal. Next up was an halibut which was beautifully cooked and had a wonderful texture. Finally was the duck which was a bit of an highlight. Beautifully flavoured and succulently tender, it was extremely satisfying. There was a decent amount of duck on the plate too.

So why uninspiring? Each of the dishes were well presented and tasty but none of them were truly mind-blowing. To my mind that's what one should be getting in a three star restaurant. The heavy use of ingredients like foie gras, caviar and truffle gave the meal and air of decadence but also the impression of "posh food by numbers". Nothing was enormously surprising nor terribly exciting. The general sense of disaffection was brought to a head by the prices. Nobody expects a three star restaurant to be cheap but the prices we were charged were verging on the piss-taking. Fifty quid for a main course. Really? We both agreed that for the sort of money we paid we were expecting a meal that we would be talking about for years to come. We were prepared to pay lots but what we did pay, didn't represent value.

Unfortunately the service didn't do a lot to counteract our general dissatisfaction. The restaurant was very well staffed but this lead to lots of people milling about trying to look busy. This in turn created a bustling atmosphere which was extremely unsettling. There was also lots of duplication of tasks. I got asked about my wine three times by three separate people before I had even had a chance to taste it (and anybody that knows me will know that it doesn't take me long to get stuck into a drink). This was after the sommelier looked slightly perplexed when I asked for his recommendations for wine to go with my meal. Throughout the meal we were interrogated as to the food often mid-mouthful or half way through a sentence making it extremely difficult either to enjoy the meal or relax and enjoy each other's company.

I did like the bread basket though. It was made out of beautifully baked and glazed dough.

In conclusion, I really can't recommend going here unless you desperately want to go to a three star restaurant that's not in London and you don't like the idea of the Fat duck  While the food is certainly delicious, it does not justify the price charged. Meals of similar quality can be obtained elsewhere for a more reasonable price. Other venues also have far more personality and soul rather than a rather stiff routine that felt in hindsight like a bit of a gastronomic conveyor belt.

TFB

Wednesday, 5 June 2013

Michelin Stars

I found this video on youtube the other morning. It's a documentary about Michelin stars (well you didn't expect it to be about AA Rosettes given the post title) examining the single minded determination with which chefs pursue them and what they mean to the everyday diner.

For something that started out as a guidebook to garages, the Michelin guide has taken on an almost biblical role in the restaurant review world. Reputations are made and lost on what it says. If you don't believe me, watch the programme. One person interviewed tells of French restaurants that go out of business shortly after losing stars. However is this reputation deserved and is there a bias towards classic French cooking over other styles of food?

My experience of Michelin cooking is limited. Going to restaurants with stars tends to be reserved as a treat for a special occasion. However my opinion based on that experience is that, at the one star level, the food is often at a par with non-starred eateries. That's not a negative comment towards the stars and more a positive comment towards the other places. Where I have noticed the difference is in the style of food and the style of service. In the one star places I have eaten, the food has always had a very French bias with the emphasis on delicately prepared ingredients that have been artfully presented. The word rustic could never apply! Similarly the service tends to be a bit more formal, almost like a dance where both the customer and the waiters know the steps. Compare this to the non-starred places where the food is still beautifully prepared and presented but is often much less fussy and fiddly. The service too is usually a bit more relaxed.

Strangely at the two and three star places I have eaten the opposite is true; when it comes to the service. As the number of stars increases, the service gets more relaxed and friendly. As I said in my post about Gordon Ramsay's three star restaurant, I was expecting the whole atmosphere to be very stuffy and yet it wasn't. It was still very dignified but guests and staff were united by a shared passion for food and the desire to make an experience of the whole event.

The conclusion in the programme was that Michelin stars were, if not over-hyped, then certainly not worth the deference they receive. It also suggested that there was still a distinct bias towards traditional French cooking and were not always a totally reliable guide. Instead they were a good means of motivating chefs to greater feats of achievement and skill.

I would disagree with some elements of this. Perhaps at the one-star end of the scale the guide can award a few too many. That's not to say that the restaurants that have them do not deserve them but acknowledges the fact that there are other restaurants that are equally as deserving. Then again, if I were a chef I would want one. They are not necessarily an absolute indicator of cooking prowess in the same way that exam grades don't always accurately reflect subject knowledge but everyone still wants an A anyway. Stars are however a good indicator of good, consistent cooking, fresh ingredients and showcasing of good produce and therefore can be a useful indicator for places to eat if one is new to an area or unfamiliar with what it has to offer. They are also a useful means of recognising and rewarding efforts expended by chefs.

Best of all in my opinion, Michelin inspectors guide their identity jealously. This means that their experience is hopefully about as close to the service received by normal customers as is possible to get by professional food critics. I like this philosophy and I think it bodes well for customer service. Michael Caines put it brilliantly when he was interviewed for the programme when he said that he treats every customer as if they are a Michelin inspector because they could well be.

So in conclusion; Michelin stars might not be the absolute epitome of good cooking but you would struggle to get a bad plate of food there.

TFB