Showing posts with label Restaurant Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Restaurant Review. Show all posts

Monday, 3 February 2014

Restaurant Review: No. 1 The Folley

Everyone has a little local gem don't they? A great little place that is just around the corner and does cracking food at a reasonable price. Usually it will take no more than five minutes to get to and have readily available tables.

Until recently I was lacking one. Nowhere in the local area really stood out. There was an anonymous looking place on the way into town. It made it securely on to the  'to go' list but we somehow never quite made it there. However recently there was a special offer on and if there is ever a good reason to investigate somewhere, it's a bargain!

And so it was that we ended up at No. 1 Folley Bridge.

I will tell you the details shortly but let me tell you my lasting impression first; overwhelming disappointment. Disappointment that I hadn't been there sooner.

The entrance is down some stairs in one of a strange collection of buildings that is on an island in the Thames. This unassuning entrance conceals a wonderful restaurant. Even in the evening the dining room was beautifully light and airy. The room was broken up with some elegant decoration an nicely ambient jazz was playing. However the main feature was the glass wall looking out on to the river and the pontoon that serves as a dining room extension. At night this was impressive. I can imagine a summer evening being breathtaking.

Now before this turns into an interior design blog, let me give you some more details. The staff were friendly and attentive without fussing. They took our orders swiftly and without note pads... nice touch!

Now to the food. It was sensational. I had some delicious scallops as a starter. They were perfectly cooked, meltingly tender and served with some delicious potatoes. Cat had some beautiful crab ravioli.

My main course was duck with potatoes cooked in the fat. I probably should have felt guilty eating duck given we regularly feed the ducks only 50 meters away from where I was eating.  The crispy skin combined with the beautifully pink flesh and the substantial portion soon banished any of these thoughts. Poached eggs put a stop to myle trying any of Cat's halibut but it looked delicious.

All of the dishes were beautifully presented and decently plentiful. The service was reasonably swift and the whole experience wonderfully relaxing. Price-wise, like I say we had a special offer. However looking at the menu, the prices offer excellent value at normal rates. My only one minor gripe is that the wine measures were a bit in the small side.

So a conclusion. I have my new local gem. We will be going back there repeatedly. Not only is it worth a visit while living locally,  it is worth travelling to for a meal.

TFB

Sunday, 19 January 2014

Restaurant Review: Byron Burger

I'm not the greatest fan of chain restaurants (despite my positive reviews of some in my post date food). Generally the thought of turning out exactly the same dishes time after time, day after day in venues across the country is a bit boring in soulless. I also don't like the idea of swelling the coffers of a corporate giant when there are lots of small, passionate chefs and restaurateurs out there struggling to get by.

So with all this in mind it may come as a bit of a surprise to hear that a couple of weeks ago I paid a visit to the latest chain to be making it's mark in the UK; Byron Burger. An American-style burger bar specialising in... you guessed it. Burgers!

It won't lie; my reason for visiting was entirely due to peer pressure. Friends banged on about it so incessantly that eventually I capitulated and decided to give it ago. As well as a latent spirit of exploration, I thought it would be fun to get some innovative ideas for things to do with burgers.

Our first impressions were good. Excellent even. We were greeted by the waitress in a warm, friendly way that so many places aspire to yet so many aspire to. I also really liked the decoration. If I were the pretentious, flouncy type I would describe it as "shabby chic" however I'm not so I will opt for decaying elegance.Lots of exposed brickwork and nothing too polished.

The menu was refreshingly simple and straight forward with only a few signature dishes available. This stopped an endless internal and external debate over what to have and gave enticing prospect of quality. It wasn't just the food menu I was impressed by. The beer menu was excellent too. Not only did it have an impressive selection of local beers, there was a good range of American craft beers.

Starters were limited. There was a choice between nachos with salsa or olives. See what I mean? But we didn't come for starters. Refreshingly, both the nachos and the accompanying salsa and guacamole were hand made rather than scooped out of a packet. They also arrived with reasonable speed.

My main course was the rather festively named triple cheesmas burger which, surprisingly was a burger smothered in three types of cheese. It was delicious. The Scottish beef (added plus points) was cooked to a beautiful medium rare and melted deliciously in the mouth. The bun had a lovely consistency and the chips were not only deliciously crunchy but perfectly seasoned. I also really liked the courgette chips I pinched from my then girlfriend (see previous post) which were cooked in a light and crispy batter - well we wouldn't want it being too healthy would we. Unfortunately, the giant pile of burger and bun, while visually appealing, was almost impossible to eat to utterly impossible to consume with any degree of grace of elegance. Not somewhere to go on a first date!

This was relative small fry though. Timings proved the biggest disappointment. The starters arrived towards the end of the acceptable time limit for starters. All very well but slightly concerning given the restaurant was virtually empty. Worse still, the main courses arrived within only minutes of our starter. Having the two in front of us simultaneously was distinctly off putting and meant that we didn't really have the opportunity to enjoy the starter. Not only was it a bit galling to be paying for something that we didn't really enjoy, I hate seeing food wasted.

So overall, I like the feel of the restaurant. The food is excellent and well thought out. Not only that, the burgers manage to be interesting without being naff. As well as all this, the staff are excellent. It's just a shame that the two courses turned up in such quick succession. I think next time I have one, I might be trying it as a takeaway.

TFB

Saturday, 9 November 2013

Restaurant Review: The Waterside Inn Bray

It was the third anniversary of my girlfriend and I getting together and what better way to for two budding foodies to celebrate a special occasion than by going out for a meal? More in hope than in faith we applied (yes applied) for table reservations at the Waterside Inn. The other three Michelin starred restaurant in Bray.

Much to our surprise, our application was successful so on the day of our anniversary we packed into the car and headed off to Bray. When we got there, we encountered the first issue of the night. Valet parking. In front of us was a fleet of Audis, behind a queue of Range Rovers. We however were in a Corsa. A pink Corsa. Needless to say, we felt a wee bit out of place. The parking attendant did however have the good grace to keep a straight face... just!

We got in and were greeted in hushed, deferential tones although it was not immediately clear whether these were directed at us or the institution. In the waiting room we were presented with menus, canapés and a drink.

Fairly quickly I decided that the tasting menu was the order of the day. So far so good. Unfortunately, when I highlighted my egg allergy, things started to go a bit wrong. I thought that, as dishes with eggs were highlighted on the menu, the kitchen would be well versed in mitigating their use. Apparently not. The waiter seemed rather flummoxed and unsettled by my revelation. Ultimately this resulted in me getting most of the dishes but some were missing elements. This I could cope with but where I felt really let down were the dessert courses. My first was substituted with a cheese board which wasn't entirely bad news. The second was substituted with a plate of fruit. This was more suitable to places where Michelins are fitted rather than awarded. Given Roux is a noted pastry chef amongst his other talents, I expected better. I was similarly let down by the petit fours with coffee. Four rather bland fruit jellies were hardly a substitute and left me feeling distinctly fobbed off.

What didn't help was a bit of a language barrier. Having a degree in Biology along with living with food allergies for 27 years means I have come to understand allergies rather well. If I hear how eggs feature in a dish, I usually have a fairly good idea how I will react to them (as well as having a decent chance of explaining why). Unfortunately the waiter and I couldn't find a common language for me to say this so in the end, I gave up.

So beyond that, how was the rest of the food? If I were to sum it up in one sentence it would be: nice but uninspiring. My lobster starter was delicious but spoiled by the heap of green stuff that looked like it had come straight out of a supermarket salad bag and gave the dish the feel of being served in a greasy-spoon "caff" rather than a world renowned restaurant. Next was a very tasty chestnut and champagne veloute with a lovely mouth-feel and mine was served without the foie gras. However it was a bit on the heavy side for something so early in the meal. Next up was an halibut which was beautifully cooked and had a wonderful texture. Finally was the duck which was a bit of an highlight. Beautifully flavoured and succulently tender, it was extremely satisfying. There was a decent amount of duck on the plate too.

So why uninspiring? Each of the dishes were well presented and tasty but none of them were truly mind-blowing. To my mind that's what one should be getting in a three star restaurant. The heavy use of ingredients like foie gras, caviar and truffle gave the meal and air of decadence but also the impression of "posh food by numbers". Nothing was enormously surprising nor terribly exciting. The general sense of disaffection was brought to a head by the prices. Nobody expects a three star restaurant to be cheap but the prices we were charged were verging on the piss-taking. Fifty quid for a main course. Really? We both agreed that for the sort of money we paid we were expecting a meal that we would be talking about for years to come. We were prepared to pay lots but what we did pay, didn't represent value.

Unfortunately the service didn't do a lot to counteract our general dissatisfaction. The restaurant was very well staffed but this lead to lots of people milling about trying to look busy. This in turn created a bustling atmosphere which was extremely unsettling. There was also lots of duplication of tasks. I got asked about my wine three times by three separate people before I had even had a chance to taste it (and anybody that knows me will know that it doesn't take me long to get stuck into a drink). This was after the sommelier looked slightly perplexed when I asked for his recommendations for wine to go with my meal. Throughout the meal we were interrogated as to the food often mid-mouthful or half way through a sentence making it extremely difficult either to enjoy the meal or relax and enjoy each other's company.

I did like the bread basket though. It was made out of beautifully baked and glazed dough.

In conclusion, I really can't recommend going here unless you desperately want to go to a three star restaurant that's not in London and you don't like the idea of the Fat duck  While the food is certainly delicious, it does not justify the price charged. Meals of similar quality can be obtained elsewhere for a more reasonable price. Other venues also have far more personality and soul rather than a rather stiff routine that felt in hindsight like a bit of a gastronomic conveyor belt.

TFB

Monday, 23 September 2013

Loch Fyne

After my recent post singing the praises of national chain restaurants; my most recent one has turned out to be rather disappointing. The restaurant in question was the Bath branch of Loch Fyne where we stopped for some lunch when we were on a day trip.

For the uninitiated, Loch Fyne is a chain of seafood restaurants that specialise in seafood from the eponymous Scottish loch. As such the food has a strongly Scottish theme running through it. Naturally I had high hopes and I was looking forward to a taste of home. Unfortunately, things didn't quite work out that way.

My first gripe comes from our introduction. Our waitress showed us to our table before introducing herself and reeling off a spiel more suited to a pre-flight briefing. While this may be considered charming in some parts of the world, we Brits want burgers not biographies. Everyone in this act realised this and it quickly created a slightly awkward atmosphere.

Next was the food. While lunchtime set menus are never going to be mind-bendingly brilliant, this was particularly disappointing. Our starters were very tasty and decently sized, unfortunately the main courses didn't follow suit. Both were bland and under-seasoned. In addition, my plaice was prepared in such a way that it was virtually impossible to get a decent mouthful of food. The seasonal vegetable side was much the same; under seasoned, over cooked and watery.

Such was the level of our disappointment that neither of us had the slightest desire to have dessert. We agreed that none looked particularly appetising and those that looked palatable would almost certainly be a let down. Now to put this into context; separating my girlfriend from sugar is like separating a Scotsman from a fiver... theoretically possible but in practise very difficult. Not having a dessert is a big deal!

The upshot of all this is that I can't in good conscience recommend going here. Perhaps the a la carte menu would be a better bet however, given the price of the dishes on there, it is a big risk to take.

TB

Thursday, 19 September 2013

The Black Prince

We were at an impasse. After a wonderful trip to Blenheim Palace, it was agreed that some form of refreshment was needed. The girls, being girls, were advocating a twee tea-shop. The gentlemen understood that the only honourable way to spend a sunny weekend afternoon was in a beer garden with a pint. Fortunately, such an area had been spotted a few minutes before. However, being gentlemen, we capitulated and trudged off into a dingy world of rocking tables, slow service and stale cakes.

Eventually even the girls had to admit, grudgingly,that they were wrong and so started my first ever encounter with the subject of this post.

The Black Price is a coaching inn on the main road that runs through Woodstock going North. The building looks old but unimposing from the outside however it stands out almost instantly with a magnificent garden that has well tended flowers, Aunt Sally, plenty of seating and a river running along it's Southern border. The latter was gratefully frequented by some of the canine patrons. An additional bonus was a large car park.

The inside was equally lovely with exposed stone walls and floors. There was lots of seating round the walls and big tables to eat at. In one corner was a large open fire which looked like it made the whole building wonderfully cosy in the winter months. Two features I particularly liked were the suit of armour guarding the door (although it does have the tendency to assault one on the way to the loo) and the fact that the optics were attached directly to the wall rather than to a bar.

My initial foray into the Black Prince was simply for drinks. The bar hosts an impressive range of real ales that are very well kept and change regularly enough to stay interesting. Prices are excellent and the staff are uniformly friendly and charming. Four-legged guests are also given a warm welcome with plenty cuddles and treats which was appreciated by my girlfriend's parent's dog when he puts in an appearance.

However it is not just a drinking pub. It is a wonderful place to eat. There is an extensive menu of standard "pub grub" (pies, fish and chips, burgers, etc). Although unfussy and unpretentious, the food is always beautifully prepared with hearty portions; almost enough to sate my appetite! I have eaten there many times and each time has been an unqualified joy. Better still, the prices are extremely reasonable (usually no more than £10 for a main course) making it the perfect place to default to on the rare occasions when cooking seems like too much of a chore and the freezer is empty.

Finally for commendation is the £5 menu. It is, as the name suggests, a menu on which all the dishes cost five pounds. Somewhat unkindly I was expecting meagre portions of rubbish from this but I can happily say that I'm wrong. The portions are perfect for a hearty lunch of a light dinner and again, beautifully cooked. A fantastic example of value for money.

In conclusion; if you're in Oxfordshire and you're looking for a reasonably priced good-quality meal or even a quiet drink in a scenic setting you will struggle to beat here.

TFB

Tuesday, 27 August 2013

Restaurant Review: The Running Horse

Hampshire is known for it's horses. New Forest Ponies are known internationally despite their habit of picking fights with cars. Moving away from postcards and on to betting slips, a famous stud farm and racing stables are within the county's borders.

Next door is the Running Horse pub. Unsurprisingly, it has a bit of a racing theme. However, despite this, gimmicks are not the stock in trade here. Good food and excellent beer are the front runners.

The pub has recently come under new management. As well as refurbishing the interior, the kitchen is cooking up a storm. Fresh, local produce is very much the order of the day. Not only was most of it alive until very recently (and in some cases, running around), it is beautifully prepared.

My starter was rope grown moules marinier. The mussels were plentiful; the sauce rich and creamy with just the right amount of garlic. It was served with a slice of toast, which seemed like a bit of an afterthought, and a spoon for the delicious sauce. There were enough mussels for a hearty starter and the remaining sauce filled any residual gaps.

The main course was roasted guinea-fowl with fondant potatoes, onion puree and a hazelnut/madiera sauce. It was magnificent. The guinea-fowl was rich and succulent with an intense flavour. The fondant potato light and fluffy with a delicious, earthy flavour. Everything was topped off perfectly by the sweet, rich sauce. There were a couple downsides to the dish. Firstly, the plate was lettered with some green gunk. I can only presume it was there for colour as it didn't look appetising. Painting a strategic bit on the plate might be a better alternative. Second was the fact that the dish was almost 20 minutes late. Unfortunately it had been missed off the order. To their credit, the staff handled it well and with great tact assuring me that it was being cooked at warp speed 6! Was it worth it? I think so.

Dessert was my traditional cheese board. There were a delicious variety of rich cheeses combined with plenty biscuits and some rather nice chutney. A perfect mix of tangy and creamy flavours which rounded off the meal nicely

All of this was washed down with a couple of pints of Tipster, an ale from the brewery owned by the company. Again, the emphasis on local produce! Although the beer wasn't brewed especially for the pub, it was still a nice touch.

The interior of the pub was elegantly decorated without the surroundings stealing the show from the food. A particular feature I liked were the tweed coverings on the cushions of the bench seats. The tables were uniformly large so there was always plenty space to spread out food, drinks and limbs.

Overall, well worth a visit. The delay in my main course lost it a few points but everyone makes mistakes and I'm more than happy to give it the benefit of the doubt for the first time.

TFB

Thursday, 15 August 2013

Restaurant Review: Limewood

Like a second album for a successful band, a second restaurant for a successful chef can be a tough challenge. Too similar to the original venture and they run the risk of being branded formulaic and unoriginal. Too different and they risk losing some of the magic that brought them success in the first place. The process can't be any easier with fans and food critics alike, poised with baited breath, awaiting the latest offering. Such were the challenges faced by Angela Hartnett and Luke Holder when they opened their new restaurant in Limewood.

Both chefs have an impeccable fine-dining pedigree, having worked in a constellation of Michelin Starred restaurants. Both have a strong Italian influence in their cooking. This Italian streak pervades through the entire experience. The building itself, set in the middle of the New Forest, was built to reflect Italian architecture with the main bar being set out like a central Piazza. A huge sliding roof allows vast amounts of natural light in and gives the space a lovely, airy feel. More to the point, the bar mixed the first decent negroni I've had since I lived with an Italian! A selection of lighter, less potent cocktails were available for the faint-hearted. I was also impressed by the extensive range of single malts available. Their ranks included some of my all time favourites.

The food had a very strong Italian feel to it with lots of pasta and rich tomato sauces on the menu, which itself was laid out in the style of a traditional Italian restaurant rather than starter, main and dessert.

On the subject of the menu; A3 sheets of card were just a bit big and unwieldy to handle at the table especially when we had decided what we wanted to eat and were ready to continue our conversation. Finding somewhere to put them on the already cramped table was a bit of a pain.

As well as being small, the tables became very cluttered when the main dishes were brought along with various side dishes. Cutlery, crockery, wine and food stayed on more by luck than design. The tables were also very close together. Had it been busier, I can imagine the dining room getting quite claustrophobic.

Despite these niggles, the food was mostly excellent. My starter, an antipasti of meats which were smoked and cured in house, was delicious and beautifully presented on a wooden block. A main course of cockles, plaice and smoked sweetcorn was equally tasty although I didn't really notice the chilli that claimed to be in there. My side of potatoes was delicious but erring on the oily side. Dessert was the usual cheeseboard which claimed to have a mix of Italian and British cheeses. I would have appreciated a brief explanation of each of the cheeses so I could have got a rough idea of which one was which. That said, I liked the concept and (crucially) there were plenty of biscuits to go with it.

For others in the party, dessert was a bit of a let down. My girlfriend's mother ended up having a slice of cake that would have looked more at home in a tea shop and, according to her, turned out to be a bit disappointing. This was mitigated by my girlfriend's dessert of strawberry and basil panna cotta. It looked so gorgeous that I couldn't help but pinch a bit. The strawberries and basil combined to form a beautifully refreshing flavour. This was accentuated by the panna cotta with a deliciously smooth, delicate texture.

As I said, the food at Limewood was delicious. However I think it suffered a bit from stylistic indecision. The website claims it to be 'fun dining not fine dining'. Why fine dining can't be fun I don't know but let's gloss over that. I presume this to mean they were aiming to move away from the formality and fussiness of fine dining towards a more relaxed brasserie style. I'm not sure this has been fully realised. The food and service is just a bit too formal to be brasserie but doesn't quite hit all the fine ding buttons either. Yes, it tasted fabulous but I (and the others with me) found the lack of definite focus a bit unsettling. Ultimately, a lot of thought and effort has gone into designing the experience and the branding around it. This is slightly let down by the food being served lacking direction.

So, with all this in mind, would I recommend it? Yes. The building is stunning; the setting more generally is spectacular; the atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming and (despite the fact that I spent the last paragraph nit-picking) the food was delicious too.

TFB 

Sunday, 7 July 2013

Restaurant Review: The Merchants Warwick

Things did not start well. We were on a day trip to Warwick which had proved fairly disappointing so far. Now we were hungry. Tempers were frayed and sarcastic jibes were getting less jovial and more venomous. We needed food. She was on the spy for a twee little tearoom with 'lovely' cakes or, failing that, a ghastly chain coffee shop with it's sweaty, plastic sandwiches and gratuitously loud coffee machines. I on the other hand was on the lookout for somewhere with at least the potential of providing a decent feed and maybe even some nutritional value. I do like tea and scones but let's be honest; they're not a meal.

Eventually we ended up going into the Merchants for no other reason than it was beside us when our tempers finally snapped. However it was still not plain sailing. The Merchants is a pub and that meant I had "won". She was therefore determined not to like it! Menus were eyed with suspicion bordering on disdain as flaws were looked for..

Then the food came. Two bowls of hearty soup and a portion of chips later and we were back to liking each other. Not just that; the Merchants had secured it's place in our affections. So much so, my girlfriend decided, virtually on the spot, that she wanted to return there for her birthday.

The pub itself has a lovely, relaxed atmosphere. A feature I particularly enjoyed was the menu; it was displayed on blackboards around the wall. There were also some rather amusing flow charts to help people decide the details of their dishes. What impressed us most was the philosophy with which it was run. Everything about it was truly local from the produce on the menu to the chefs in the kitchen who had trained at the local catering college. That said, it wasn't done in a pious or preachy way. The brothers who own it seem to have a genuine love of their area and care for their community.

Our second trip wasn't quite as much of a success. This time was the birthday dinner mentioned before. The first thing that lost it points was the fact that the Merchants isn't dog friendly which in turn meant that my girlfriend's beloved hound wasn't able to participate in the festivities (read scavenge food off plates). Service was also painfully slow at times. If it has been a busy night then there would have been some excuse but the night we were there, it was very quiet. Now I am the first to admit that near-constant offers of new drinks is a mite irritating, enormous gaps between drinks wasn't enormous fun either. Presenting my girlfriend's aunt with a small glass of wine was a bit of a faux pas too.

Food wise; it was good but not astonishing. I liked that the ingredients were combined in dishes to give a slightly exotic feel and move away from the traditional pints and pies associated with pub grub. However some of the execution left a bit to be desired. For a starter I had smoked trout with parsnip crisps which was rather nice. The only problem was that it was tangled up in a mire of superfluous green stuff which had to be waded through and picked apart. Net result: I was left feeling frustrated and a bit unsatisfied.

Things picked up with my main course. I had a delicious chicken dish with risotto and chorizo. There was just enough spice to make everything interesting and the chorizo was fried to the point of being slightly crispy giving a lovely blend of textures as well as flavours. Critically, there was also a decent amount on the plate and it was unencumbered by rabbit food. I also had a chance to try the herby pancakes stuffed with cheese and mushrooms. I surprised myself by really rather liking the vegetarian option. The addition of herbs to the pancakes made the dish lively and the mushrooms gave a nice texture to it. One down side was that the sweet-potato chips were a bit limp and greasy although they tasted fabulous. Given that the pancakes were very generously proportioned I might also be a bit controversial and say that two per portion was a bit on the generous side!

Desert was, as always, a cheese board. I found the selection of cheese (a cheddar, brie and blue cheese) a bit uninspiring but this was mitigated a) by hearty portion sizes and b) by the fact that I was provided with sufficient biscuits and bread to be able to eat all the cheese. I always find it enormously frustrating when tucking into a decent cheeseboard when I run out of means to eat it and have to try and juggle various morsels to get them to my mouth. My girlfriend had the chocolate brownie and I can only guess from the fervour with which it was demolished, that it was quite nice!

So overall conclusion? Despite my grumblings, I would strongly recommend this place for a decent plate of food at a reasonable price. Yes the wait was a bit irksome but ultimately it was good food and enhanced by the fact it was sourced locally and prepared by locals not microwaved from the freezer.

TFB

Friday, 28 June 2013

The Kingham Plough

Gastropubs have always been a source of suspicion for me. The concept seems straight forward enough: a pub that serves excellent food. In practise though, things are rarely that simple. Often the term "Gastropub" is a synonym for a restaurant that is being run from an old pub building. A rose (or maybe Rose and Crown) by any other name as it were. These can be quite well concealed from the outside and only display their true colours (mainly white from the starched linen) once you cross the threshold. While I like formal silver service with all the trimmings, there's a time and a place. In the pub when you're looking for a quiet pint is neither.

At the other end of the scale are the perfectly decent pubs that use the prefix "Gastro" and/or overly elaborate menus (often featuring purple sprouting broccoli or shavings of parmesan) to bung a hefty price tag on to otherwise mediocre food. The kind of place where one has to choose from a vast array of breads when selecting one's lunchtime sandwich to go with your pint then being relieved of about fifteen quid for the privilege.

The above examples are bad gastropubs. What makes a good one? Well first and foremost, it has to be a pub. Somewhere comfortable and welcoming where one can relax, have a pint and generally let one's hair down, either sitting in the corner with the paper or with friends. It also has to serve excellent food. I am of the opinion that fine dining has it's place and that place is in restaurants. Pub food should be wholesome, hearty and not too fussy (although this should not be a barrier to quality).

Does such a mythical place exist? Until recently I had my doubts. Some things are perhaps too good to be true. However that was before I discovered the Kingham Plough.

This little gem first came on to my radar when I moved to Oxford and started looking at places to eat. The menu looked delicious yet unpretentious, the surroundings looked idyllic and the general attitudes expressed on the website gave me the impression that it ticked all the boxes. An appearance by head chef Emily on the Great British Menu didn't hurt it's appeal either.

We have now been a couple of times under various pretexts and I can confidently (and happily) say that it exceeded our wildest hopes and expectations. Even the drive there was an absolute joy, taking in, as it did, some magnificent Cotswold's countryside.

The pub itself is at the very heart of the village of Kingham, just by the village green. The building is built from beautiful Cotswold stone with a large car park out the back and a garden for dogs/kids to burn off some steam.

Once inside, the pub has a lovely rustic feel with solid wooden furniture, tweed upholstery on the chairs and decorating the windows, and lovely exposed stone walls hung with pictures by local artists. So far we have only been in summer but I expect the genuine log fire will only add to the ambience during the winter months. After a tantalising glance into the kitchen one enters the main bar.

The bar scores major brownie points with me for being a proper bar not just a few bar stools grudgingly laid out next to a meagre offering in the corner. It is well stocked with a good range of local ales, spirits (including some rather good malts), an extensive wine list and an impressive looking humidor. Beyond all this though, it feels like a really cosy local. This is only enhanced by the (very sensible) dog friendly policy.

Off to one side is the dining room with tables set out more formally. One feature of the dining room I particularly liked was the lighting. It managed to be gentle and soft without ever making the room feel dingy and dark. Not an easy feat to pull off.

The pub is run by husband and wife team Miles and Emily. As Emily was off on maternity leave during our visits we have yet to have the pleasure of meeting her, however Miles was a true character and started our night with a bang. He is a master of non-verbal communication and is able to speak volumes with a nod of the head or a raised eyebrow. His welcome set the tone for the evening; very relaxed and casual making us feel completely at home. This was continued by the other staff who were extremely friendly and soon had us feeling like we were long-lost friends catching up. All of this gave huge warmth to the evening. Most importantly, it didn't have the forced and false feeling of the scripted "banter" in some imported chain restaurants.

Sadly, there was one key member of the team we did not get to meet. Someone who managed to cement our good impressions of the pub before we even got close. Her name is Ootie and she's the pub Jack Russel who, according to her blog on the pub's website, does like pork scratchings and tummy tickles but is emphatically NOT cute! It's a shame really. Since we're both massive dog-lovers we had treats secreted about our person in expectation of meeting her.

Anyway without further ado, let me get on to the food. If you want a one word summary then let it be this, "Wowitwasbloodyfantastic!" (ok slight artistic licence there but I am quarter German so I'm allowed to use compound words). Not only was the flavour amazing but the nigh-on impossible was achieved: the portion sizes were judged to perfection. They left me (a reformed rower with an equine appetite) feeling suitably sated while not over feeding my girlfriend's mother who has the stomach capacity of a sparrow with a gastric band. I swear the plates must have been made by the same person who made the tardis.

My starters at various points were smoked mackrel with bloody mary sorbet or duck terrine with lentil salad. Both were beautiful with rich, bold flavours and a lovely array of textures and temperatures. Each had me desperate for more. The food was artfully presented on the plate without being fussy which is always a relief since it means one doesn't have to chase several elements round a plate to get a decent mouthful.

The main course caused me to break one of my main rules of eating out; I had the same dish twice. Usually I wouldn't dream of this so I get to try a decent amount of variety. Each time I went to the Kingham Plough however I had the steak, chips and onion rings. The flavour of the steak was unbelievable (quite the best bit of skirt I've ever had... well skirt beef anyway), the onion rings beautifully crispy and the triple-cooked chips light, fluffy and crispy.  I can also confidently recommend the chicken with the cock-a-leekie pie; the few scavenged morsels I managed to get my mitts on were delicious.

Dessert was my customary cheese board; I liked being able to choose between various local cheeses and I particularly liked the fact that as well as more mainstream cheeses there were some slightly left-field choices such as a range of sheep's cheese. This reflects one of the main philosophies of the Kingham Plough; local produce. Most of what is cooked is produced within about ten miles of the pub. The cheese board also scored major brownie points with me for having enough biscuits/bread to have all the cheese. The lack thereof is a pet hate.

Finally, with coffees we had the selection of sweets. These are an absolute must. Usually there is a fudge, a truffle, a muffin and a jelly. All are absolutely delicious and were a perfect way to round off the meal. I was genuinely impressed by the fact that the sweets had taken flavours I'm usually not a fan of (such as banana) and made them delicious.

Overall, I really can't find fault with either of my experiences at the Kingham Plough (apart from lack of dog). The quality of the food and the cooking was superb, the surroundings were magnificent and the atmosphere was just perfect. I can't think of a better goal for other gastropubs to aim for. My opinions were shared by my girlfriend and her family. None of us can stop raving about it (as this post may suggest). In fact the only individual who was anything less than bowled over was her parent's dog who came with us the second time and who didn't get nearly as many titbits as he thought he ought to get!

We will be going back soon.

TFB